
Schisma iam factum est
The
Catholic Church is on the Brink of Schism

and this
man is the cause
“Feelings” “Emotions” and “Desires”
Is
this what the Synod on Synodality is based upon
Can it Really Be This Banal?
In
a word — given
the very first question proposed to the “participants” — the
answer is, “Yes.”
The aptly
abbreviated SOS (Synod on Synodality) appears
to be, in its first days, little more than a badly dated
“Encounter Group” from the Woodstock generation (Jorge’s
generation) that conceived it.
It began
with what appears to be, for all practical purposes, an
ecclesiastical “Sensitivity Training” session setting out
the parameters for all subsequent sessions.
They will
not be concerned with critical and substantive issues
affecting the lives of Catholics in an increasingly hostile
world, nor will they address the state-sponsored suppression
of the religious liberty of Catholics world-wide, still less
the deep state’s infringement on the free expression of
Catholics in the public forum — employing all its
prosecutorial assets to subdue the expression of genuine
Catholicism — nor the apparent immunity granted to
militantly secular groups that denigrate, diminish, and
destroy what is uniquely Catholic. Neither will it attempt
to redress the persecution of traditional Catholics by the
regime of the “progressive” deep-Church of left-liberal
bishops and cardinals — a fact which the Vatican resolutely
refuses to recognize, even while it instigates it. This
burlesque called the Synod on Synodality is merely an
organ of the disaffected ecclesiastical apparatus that
unquestionably initiated it to promote its own liberal
agenda.
Let us
consider only the first question (we will be exploring the
others as well) submitted to the “participants”:
Question 1: Arousals
“Reflecting on how the synod course unfolded in the
Church where I come from, what is the prevailing spiritual
tone that characterizes it?
What emotions and feelings did
it arouse in those who took part? What desires
did it arouse in the Christian community?”
We presume
that this is not a gratuitously salacious question.
Why, we
must ask, would our emotions and feelings, our
… arousals … be of any significance to the state and
mission of the Church in the world today… and all its
members?
Is this really what the
Catholic Church should be talking about?
My
desires and emotions, my
feelings and my arousals? ...
instead of the state ... and the present trajectory
... of my immortal soul? The intimate language used
is almost startling. In fact, the question could be lifted
right out of an erotic novel:
“let’s talk about our desires, explore our feelings, delve
into our emotions … and see what really arouses
us.”
Indeed, the word “arousal” in used twice in two
succeeding sentences!
Just as the author of Heal me with your Mouth, the Art of
Kissing, by
Cardinal Victor Fernández is understood to be, in large
part, “credited” with the infamous and scandalous
Exhortation Laudato Si, The Joy of Love — a
title unquestionably borrowed from the widely known
and erotic 1962 illustrated manual The Joy of Sex,
by Alex Comfort — it is not difficult to see the same mind
at work in these opening questions.
It would be
absurd to suppose that there is no collaboration whatever
between Francis and his close friend and advisor … whom he
recently appointed to a post far beyond his native capacity.
The Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith has
always been a post requiring the deepest intellectual
credentials as well as the most profound Catholic faith,
neither of which is exemplified in Fernández. He is
decidedly pedestrian in his résumé and certainly not
sterling in his faith. But … he is “tight” with Jorge, his
fellow-countryman. and has always counted on him in an
imbroglio when his own resources have been depleted. This
alone says much about both Bergoglio and Fernández and the
common vision they share.
Unfortunately, it says even more about this “Synod” that
they have conceived and collaborated in. And it does not
bode well for the Church which, as a result of the
decisions, policies, and agenda of Francis and his
collaborators in de-Catholicizing the Church, has brought it
to the brink of schism.
Part
2. Francis and the Brinkmanship of Schism
through Synodality
Geoffrey K. Mondello
Editor
Boston Catholic Journal
October 4, 2023,
Feast of St. Francis of Assisi, Confessor, Founder of the
Order of Friars Minor